her hair absolutely fazes through her arm
but hey at least she looks hot
can /you/ do any better?
I mean god damn are you people seriously going to pick at every little thing DID YOU NOT SEE HOW FUCKING BEAUTIFUL THE BACKGROUND WAS? HOW WONDERFULLY ANIMATED THE ICE AND SNOW AND MAGIC WAS?
Not to mention how INCREDIBLE her voice sounds in this scene
But no, is all ruined because a cartoon had her hair phase through her arm
um hi as a professional 3d animator this is actually really really sloppy of them and everyone should be pointing this out
first and foremost all the backgrounds and particle effects are pretty and shiny and nice and all but it doesn’t mean anything if your character animation isn’t up to snuff because you know that’s kinda what people go to see the movie for
second there are dozens and dozens of levels of quality control in the disney studios - i’ve seen shit a thousand times less noticeable than this get people torn apart during dailies by their instructors or their superiors
lemme tell you something when i was in school one time i had spent two weeks working out a piece where a guy jumps out of a filing cabinet and there was a four frame segment where the tip of his foot collided with the edge of the cabinet as he turned around
my instructors spent almost a full half an hour drilling me on it in front of the entire class because i was too lazy to go back and fix it
so no these guys have literally no excuse whatsoever they have the best and brightest in the business and all the money in the world to back it there is absolutely no reason for that kind of supreme laziness
I do understand that it was lazy, and yes, they could’ve gone back to fix it, but I’m just kind of hurt by the fact that the sheer beauty of the rest of the scene needs to be thrown awa because of this little slip up. I’ve seen next to nothing online about how amazing the rest of the scene looks but this is the billionth time I’ve seen the ‘OH GOD HER HAIR GOES THROUGH HER ARM’ comment.
I’ve seen worse fuck-ups in a movie. I had to watch hoodwinked.
Like damn why do we have to be so negative why can’t we just appreciate the good things?
because the good things are apparent and self-evident to people usually
the thing about the negative is that it needs to be acknowledged in order for people to improve and the fact of the matter is disney has gotten INCREDIBLY LAZY recently
they’ve used the same base mesh for the last three movies or so for most of their characters, they’re letting basic school-level mistakes get through, and they are making the greatest mistake you can make in 3d animation: believing that by making everything shiny and throwing in particle effects that it will cover up the animation
these are like, 2002-era mistakes here and disney of all companies has literally NO excuse to make them - they’ve gotten incredibly complacent and full of themselves and they think that just because they’re disney they can get away with anything they want and because of this as a whole their quality has drastically fallen
like the movie is pretty, no doubt - the particle simulation ability and incredible lighting software and layers and layers of shaders all look stunning!
but there are A LOT of problems with that movie, and it’s not even remotely just limited to sloppiness in the QA department (cough lack of poc and female representation cough and ripping apart the original tale that it’s based on cough couch) , and these things really, really, really, really need to be addressed - otherwise you’re going to let the biggest name in animation set a horrendous example
feel free to love the movie for what it is but don’t get on people for correctly pointing out the numerous flaws in it’s material
No. I need to comment on this. Because mister mightier than thou here is an ass and I can’t contain my anger right now. FIRST of all, don’t even get me started on the lack of person of color in this movie. It takes place in basically fucking Scandinavia. Next time you’re in Scandinavia let me know how many native poc you see, let alone in the time period this takes place in. Second, lack of female representation? The fuck fucking movie were you watching???? Last I checked there were TWO FUCKING POWERFUL WOMEN IN THIS FILM WOW! Third, do you have any idea how many times I had to watch this to even SEE this “horrendous flaw”?? Ok, her hair goes through her arm… I guess that’s sort of an issue. Personally, I like seeing that even a powerhouse company such as Disney makes mistakes because guess what it’s run by HUMANS who are FULL OF FLAWS. It’s not lazy. Films that get released by major companies have flaws ALL THE DAMN TIME. And personally, I like going on imdb and reading the mistakes made in movies. Find me a movie that doesn’t have a flaw and THEN you can make your argument.
Go back to pouting that you don’t work for Disney Animation because I’m guessing that’s where this resentment comes from. Dick.
*insert gif of Elsa slamming door here*
Lmao best reply ever
HOW THE F*CK DID THEY GET FROM ANIMATION MISTAKES TO POC?! Jeeze people.
That reply was basically what I was thinking in my head!! People happily allow live action movies to have multiple continuity errors but cannot let a tiny animation error go? Pretty sure less people would be horrified if this was a mistake done by Dreamworks, Blue Sky etc Disney is still learning because each movie has new members everytime. Unlike the nine old men days where the same people worked together, these days new animators, technology, directors every department there are new people who like the comment said make human errors.
I’m sorry but I must agree with the “ass” here…Look, I also studied 3D animation and if you make a tiny little mistake, such as the one this guy mentioned in which just 4 frames were wrong (when 24 frames are made for just ONE SEC) it’s really annoying because everyone would tell you that you did wrong, no matter if the rest is ok…You know, 3D animation is supposed to be as close as reality as it can be, and Disney particularly has A LOT of people working on these things, mistakes like this CAN’T happen when we are talking about the biggest animation company there exist….I loved the movie, I freaking loved it, every little piece of it…but that doesn’t change the fact that this was wrong and that it shouldn’t happen. You must always point out the flaws when we talk about 3D because it makes room for these mistakes to happen again…I don’t agree that disney has drastically fallen their quality or anything…I still love them the same way I did when I was 7 years old and they were the ones who basically inspired me to start studying this and I would always love them and respect them for that…But you guys don’t need to be so rude to this guy, he is just pointing out his opinion and we should all respect that, because thanks to people like him, mistakes like this won’t happen again because Disney would realize that they did wrong in this one little scene and would try to not commit the same mistake again! I don’t think it was lazyness or anything, but I do think that these mistakes cannot happen.
Jennifer returned to filming an Oscar winner. Do you treat her differently? (x)
i held it in,
but now it seems you’ve set itrunning free.